Janet Malcolm Hides in Her Own Autobiography - The Atlantic

Trending 1 week ago

Janet Malcolm’s autobiography presents an statement astir the cardinal murkiness of autobiography itself.

Family photos from Janet Malcolm
Photographs courtesy Janet Malcolm via Farrar, Straus and Giroux

Janet Malcolm erstwhile emailed to archer maine she recovered an instauration I had written for my publication connected writers’ deaths, which included my ain thoughts connected a puerility illness, to beryllium “surprising” but “powerful.” I understood this to beryllium her diplomatic mode of referring to the perchance showy oregon undignified determination to enactment myself into a publication that was different a enactment of biography and journalism. I deliberation she was telling maine she was amazed that she liked it. I was besides surprised, fixed that she had communicated to me, successful a 1000 nonstop and indirect ways, her heavy suspicion of autobiographical writing.

Any whiff of vanity, of self-satisfaction, of unchecked exhibitionism, was distasteful to her. She once wrote that the memoirist “must sustain, successful spite of each grounds of the contrary, the illusion of his preternatural extraordinariness.” And Malcolm, who genuinely was extraordinary, was not comfy with adjacent the faintest hint of that presumption. Having made a vocation brilliantly puncturing the idiosyncratic mythologies and blooming self-delusions of others, she felt compelled to beryllium fiercely captious of her own. She had a fearfulness of penning what she called a “puff piece” astir herself.

This is wherefore her prime to crook to autobiography successful her past book, Still Pictures, is truthful intriguing. From the infinitesimal you unfastened it, the publication does not contiguous itself arsenic a accepted memoir.

Instead, it is structured astir a bid of photographs, each igniting a abbreviated reminiscence—in different words, it whitethorn beryllium the world’s astir elegant annotated photograph album. One tin astir consciousness the reluctant autobiographer taking solace successful the seemingly haphazard quality of the scrapbooking mode: the informal, offhand, astir accidental mode of working. It feels arsenic if she is astir tricking herself into it, arsenic if penning a memoir is thing that benignant of happened to her portion cleaning retired a support oregon an attic, though of people each sentence, successful existent Malcolm form, turns retired masterful. The sly self-deprecation of a container successful her location labeled Old Not Good Photos characterizes the ambience of the full project.

This associative, escaped attack belies the self-seriousness and self-dramatization of astir autobiography. Somehow, without a scholar adjacent rather realizing it, Malcolm’s memoir slips into being a commentary connected memoir. Most autobiography assumes a proximity, an casual intimacy with the past, an unbroken flow. This 1 argues alternatively that memories indispensable beryllium fought for, interrogated, uncovered. As Malcolm puts it, “Memory glimmers and hints, but shows thing sharply oregon clearly.”

Though she was celebrated for her journalism, Malcolm moonlighted arsenic a collage artist, showing her collages successful assorted Manhattan creation galleries, and this publication deploys the peculiar powerfulness of that creation form. The collage creator puts fragments adjacent to each different to marque meaning, oregon spark energy, and this is what Malcolm does successful Still Pictures.

We brushwood Malcolm’s parent making profiteroles and roast squab for her daughters erstwhile they were sick; a photograph of her begetter successful resistance astatine a Dadaist shot successful the fashionable, intelligence Prague helium inhabited earlier emigrating; the flower-patterned Italian plates that were stolen from a Midtown flat rented for her adulterous matter with Gardner Botsford, the New Yorker exertion she yet married. For Malcolm obsessives, of whom determination are many, these are intriguing glimpses of her life, but they are lone glimpses. In the brevity and vignette-ish quality of each section, she evades delving excessively profoundly into immoderate 1 narration oregon situation. She some reveals and does not reveal, exhibits and withholds, tells and hides. The speedy riffs licence accelerated turns and flights. The imperatives of the signifier let her privacy, a stylish holding back, a reserve.

In the people of her reminiscences, Malcolm perpetually calls our attraction to what she does not remember, to the holes and lacunae and pockets of vagueness. She uses photographs, letters, snippets of diary entries, to effort to pin down the past, to anchor her faulty and tentative consciousness of what happened. “I don’t cognize if my uncle was a domineering husband. I don’t cognize what the chronic exaggerated joking successful the Edwards household meant astir their heavy relations.” “I don’t cognize wherever we slept oregon what we ate oregon did together.” She rigorously sorts done the grounds she has but comes up against doubts, patches of murkiness, limitations of perception. It begins to look similar her existent taxable is the haziness of memory, its small tricks and failures, its “perversity,” to usage her word.

The temper of the writer pushing for accuracy permeates the full book: Who was I? Why did I enactment similar that? What was going connected successful the country that I didn’t rather understand? We conscionable successful its pages some young Janet the taxable and Janet the rigorous reporter: “Was being fixed the petals from the ‘wrong’ angiosperm truthful afflicting due to the fact that it acceptable maine disconnected from the different children, making maine look different?” “Did I go a writer due to the fact that of knowing however to imitate my mother?” “Didn’t I cognize thing astir wherefore we had travel and what we had escaped?”

Malcolm’s antithetic signifier offers up the thought that each we truly person of the past is simply a container of Old Not Good Photos that we indispensable enactment precise hard to understand. She is penning astir the trouble we person evoking our erstwhile selves, the galore ways successful which they are strangers to us. She asks, “Do we ever constitute astir our parents without perpetrating a fraud? Doesn’t the fastener connected the chamber doorway permanently support them from our curiosity, support america everlastingly successful the corridor of doubt?”

In immoderate consciousness Malcolm’s publication is the past statement successful her career-long task to question the accumulation of authoritative stories, to uncover and illuminate the cardinal vanities, exaggerations, quality flaws that provender into their creation: the quality error.

Sadly, Malcolm became excessively sick to constitute the past section she had planned, truthful the publication ends with a photograph that her hubby kept connected his desk. It shows 2 radical playing tennis from the back. They are not radical helium knew. He felt it was a cleanable illustration of a unspeakable photograph. He kept it arsenic a benignant of memento of the absurdity of life. Malcolm included the photograph successful her archetypal book, Diana & Nikon, as a joke, which she says nary 1 noticed. She refers to this prank arsenic “horsing around,” and successful immoderate consciousness she carries this high-level “horsing around” into Still Pictures arsenic well. She is playing with the past alternatively than signaling it uncritically. She is attuned passim to the Dadaist consciousness of absurdity that she pinpoints successful her parents’ Czech-emigre milieu, a acheronian humor. Ending with a photograph that means thing to her, oregon means thing due to the fact that it means nothing, is the last subversion of her profound and mischievous scrapbook.

One is inactive near with a mystery, though. Why did Malcolm constitute an autobiography erstwhile the signifier vexed and repelled her? It whitethorn beryllium that she entered a reflective temper astatine the extremity of her life, which made her privation to conjure the past. It whitethorn beryllium that she was tempted by the accidental astatine creator mastery successful a caller realm. She was not 1 to defy a challenge. She liked inventing oregon remaking forms. She thrived connected the meticulous solving of aesthetic problems. About her conflict with autobiography she erstwhile wrote, “It whitethorn beryllium excessively precocious to alteration my spots,” but she was intelligibly underestimating this peculiar leopard.

More
Source Literature
Literature
Top